Jason Shirtz
Improvisational Dance: Robin Collen
Improve Dance: Student taught session reflection paper
Class title "Expanding comfort zones"
Taught by Jason, Justine, and Aisha
Lesson Plan:
Warm-up activities:
Lead by Justine and Jason
-opposing motions/uncomfortable motions, lead by Justine.
-Meditation on increasing comfort zone, lead by Jason
Activity 1:
Lead by Aisha
-Walking across room as a class.
-Walking across room, Threading.
-Walking across room with a partner, eye-contact
-Proximity with an partner with their eyes closed
Activity 2:
Lead by Justine
-Personal comfort zone open improv
-Discussion
Activity 3:
Lead by Jason
-opposing motions/uncomfortable motions, with eye contact.
-improv of 'safe' actions
Bonus Activity:
lead by Justine
-'take it literal' open improv
Learning goals:
-Acknowledging personal comfort zones.
-Confronting areas of discomfort.
-Expanding personal comfort zones.
Warm-up activities:
Lead by Justine, and Jason
Opposing motion:
The plan was for Justine, warm up the class to both physical motion, and the idea of doing uncomfortable activities, by incorporating various unconventional motions into a routine. The class seemed to respond enthusiastically to Justine's energetic movements.
Meditation:
The concept her was for Jason to read a meditation on increasing comfort zones to prepare the class mentally to work on self-developing the concept in their minds first, before executing it in class. While the concepts in the meditation were well worded, and received by the class, many found Jason's reading pace, and abrupt shift after the end of the meditation jarring.
Activity 1:
Lead by Aisha
Walking across room as a class:
Leading the class across the room in a straight line was intended purely to warm up the class, and start with the simplest possible comfortable motion, before introducing more complicated ones. This seemed to work as intended.
Walking across the room, threading:
Every other person stepped back to the other end of the classroom. They then, crossed each other by one group walking forward, and the other back, building a sense of positional 'trust'. This was repeated so both halves of the class had the experienced walking backwards. This activity seemed to be successful at causing the class to feel slightly uncomfortable, and helped to prepare them for greater expansion of comfort zone later in the class.
Walking across the room with a partner, eye-contact:
This activity forced the partners to traverse the room, while keeping eye contact with an assigned partner. The assigned partners were intended to be people that the person did not necessarily have frequent contact with. This activity succeed in forcing eye contact with partners, and lead the way to introspection among the class about personal comfort levels outside of the classroom.
Proximity with a partner, with eyes closed:
This activity, where each assigned partner took turns hovering near the other, silently without the touch, while the one stood eyes closed emphasized acceptance of lack of information, trust in a stranger, and in a new situation. It turns out that some of the group found it very uncomfortable, while others felt a great sense of trust while doing it, either from prior experiences, or from noting how it worked for their partners immediately before them.
Activity 2:
Lead by Justine
-Personal comfort zone open improv
The goal of this improv, was to run two groups of the class where they were to explore their personal comfort by performing actions that defined them, or made them comfortable whether or not they were 'dance moves.' It was this section that surprised us the most, as we learned in the discussion afterwards, that much of the class was not 'comfortable' doing daily activities outside of their normal context, and that they were not comfortable performing mimics of them inside the dance studio.
Discussion:
we spent a significant portion of the time after this improv, discussing how comfort zones worked, why we were comfortable doing some things, in certain situations and not others. The class was very introspective, and we made a point of discussing some strategies/tips for expanding comfort not only of dance movements but eye contact, and miming everyday activities on the dance floor.
Activity 3:
Lead by Jason
-opposing motions/uncomfortable motions, with eye contact.
The goal of this improv, was to repeat the same opposing motions/uncomfortable motions introduced in the warm-up with Justine, but add in the 'extra' element of maintaining eye contact with the assigned partners at the same time. This one took several elements of our class, and put them together in an excellent activity that challenged the class to put together what they had learned into a new technique. The class found it daunting, but rose to the challenge quite well.
-improv of 'safe' actions
The goal of this was for the class to default into a routine of "safe" actions that they had explored while in the prior improv lead by Justine. This worked fairly well, and seemed to be a success.
Bonus Activity:
Lead by Justine
"make it literal" improv
In this impromptu addition to our class plan, Justine lead the class in one more 'personal comfort' improv, but this time told them to 'make it literal' and perform physical actions as if they were in the actual environment that they occurred in. This lead to a much stronger response from the class than the prior improv, and did much to expand both their knowledge of where their comfort zone was, as help them to see how to expand it further.
Class Final Discussion:
At the end of the class session, we had many, many questions and comments concerning how to recognize, and improve personal comfort levels. It was apparent that much of the class had taken certain things for granted, such as contextual comfort with day-to-day activities, and where they put their eye contact in ordinary social situations.
It seemed that the class had a very robust discussion of the activities of the day, and that overall they left the room with a greater knowledge of how to self-improve their ability to feel comfortable both doing new things, and become more comfortable with old activities.
Personal Insights:
One of the things that truly struck me in this class, was how many of my classmates opened up about having been shy or uncomfortable in social situations, or with eye contact. While some seemed like they had been naturally comfortable in those areas their whole lives, that seemed to be the exception rather than the norm. Additionally, the class discussions were possibly the most lively of the semester with the greatest variety of participants. It seemed that Justine, Aisha, and I needed to put considerable effort into both interpreting, and the answering their questions in terms of comfort zones, as well as composing new follow up questions and activities for situations and needs we had not anticipated. Overall we did so with a high degree of both composure, and seemed successful as teachers in adapting to the needs of our class, which was very fulfilling as instructors.
As far as team dynamics go, I could not have asked for better partners than Justine, or Aisha for this project. All three of us contributed actively to the planning and formation of each activity. During the planning processes, we frequently built on and expanded on each other's ideas, while making sure to edit out and trim any excess complexity from our lesson plan. Aisha was very helpful in keeping up with the notes and paperwork, and Justine was good at keeping the group in contact with each other.
During the actual teaching of the class, I felt we worked well in adapting to the needs of the class, as well as coming up with new activities, questions, and thoughts on the subject matter on the fly. If there was any weakness in our lesson, it was my occasional foot-in-the mouth, which while slightly detrimental to the class, did not seem more than a minor, if not regrettable weakness to our presentation.
Overall, I felt the class was a rousing success in terms of concept, planning, teamwork, execution, the growth our students, and our growth as teachers.